Sanibel’s Cutest Shops and Hidden Boutiques Revealed

Let’s be honest—no beach vacation is complete without a little retail therapy. And on Sanibel Island, the shopping scene is anything but cookie-cutter. Whether you’re searching for locally made art, coastal decor, shell-inspired jewelry, or the perfect souvenir that isn’t a cheesy T-shirt (although we have those too 😉), this island is packed with charming boutiques and hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

Here’s your insider guide to the must-visit shops on Sanibel where you're sure to leave with something you love (and maybe a few extra things you didn’t know you needed). And, if you're looking for fabulous beachfront condo for your Sanibel trip check out our vacation rentals here!

🐚 1. She Sells Sea Shells

It’s more than a tongue twister—it’s a local icon. This whimsical shop on Periwinkle Way is filled with all things shell-related, from handcrafted jewelry and ornaments to unique gifts and Sanibel-themed décor. Perfect for kids, collectors, and anyone obsessed with beachy charm.

What to snag: Shell wind chimes, sand dollar ornaments, beachy baby gifts.

🎨 2. Tower Gallery

Love art? Don’t miss this quirky, colorful high end co-op gallery tucked into a historic beach cottage. It’s run by local artists, and everything here—from paintings and sculpture to hand-painted furniture—is created right on the islands.

What to snag: A one-of-a-kind painting or piece of driftwood art to remember your trip.

🌺 3. Tuttle’s Sea Horse Shell Shop

Old-school in the best possible way. This classic Sanibel stop has been around for decades and is packed with authentic Florida kitsch. Think seashell mirrors, vintage signs, shark teeth, and goofy gifts your inner 10-year-old will love.

What to snag: Affordable souvenirs, funny signs, shell magnets, and those little resin alligator figurines.

🐚 4. Captiva Curio Cottage

Tucked away like a true island secret, this charming cottage shop on Sanibel is

filled with coastal treasures, beach-themed home decor, and clever gifts. It’s the kind of place where every corner reveals something new and delightful. You’ll find unique pieces that feel like a little slice of Sanibel to take home.

What to snag: Driftwood wall art, quirky home accents, and unique gifts for your furry friend you won’t find in big-box stores.

Captiva Curio Cottage on Periwinkle Way

🕯️ 5. Suncatchers’ Dream

This cozy shop lives up to its name with a dreamy mix of island-inspired decor, local jewelry, gifts, candles, and handmade wind chimes. It’s the kind of place where you’ll say “just five minutes” and lose an hour (happily).

What to snag: Beachy scented candles, watercolor prints, and a glass sun catcher for your kitchen window.

📚 6. MacIntosh Books

A Sanibel treasure since 1960, MacIntosh Books is the perfect blend of charm and character. This independent bookstore is known for its thoughtfully curated collection of fiction, beach reads, children’s books, and island history. The warm and welcoming vibe makes it easy to lose track of time—and leave with a bag full of great finds.

What to snag: A guide to local wildlife, your next beach read, or a charming Sanibel-themed children’s book for your grandkid.

🛒 7. The Shops at Periwinkle Place

This charming open-air shopping village is home to several boutiques, galleries, and a great playground for the kids. It’s shaded, peaceful, and just the right size for a mini spree.

Shops to check out:

• The Original Chico’s – Yep, it all started right here.

• Pandora’s Box – Eclectic and full of personality.

• Sanibel Olive Oil Company – Tasty samples and great gifts to take home.

💡 Local Tips for Your Shopping Adventure:

• Bring a reusable tote or beach bag—you’ll use it.

• Many shops are locally owned—your purchases directly support island families.

• Stop for a smoothie or ice cream between stores (you’ll thank us later).

• Don’t wait until the last day! Some shops close early or take a day off midweek.

Final Thoughts:You may come to Sanibel for the sunsets, shelling, and beach days—but don’t sleep on the shopping. The boutiques here are full of heart, and many of them carry things you simply won’t find anywhere else. So whether you're picking up a few gifts, refreshing your wardrobe, or treating yourself just because... Sanibel shopping is a vibe.

Let us know your favorite finds—we love hearing what treasures our guests take home!