Fall Fun on Sanibel Island: Autumn Activities & Festivities 2025

While much of the country is trading flip-flops for flannel, fall on Sanibel Island keeps things warm, breezy, and beautiful. With fewer crowds, cooler temps, and plenty of outdoor charm, autumn is an ideal time to experience the island at a slower, more relaxed pace. Whether you're here for a beachy getaway or a seasonal escape, here’s how to make the most of Sanibel Island this fall.

1. Quieter Beaches, Better Shelling

Fall is prime time for beachgoers who love peace and space. The summer crowds thin out, the Gulf waters remain warm, and the beaches are scattered with early seasonal shells thanks to the shifting tides. Bowman’s Beach and Lighthouse Beach are perfect for a peaceful morning walk or a sunset shell-hunting session.

2. Sanibel Island Farmer's Market Returns

Starting on Sunday, October 5th, the Sanibel Island Farmer’s Market kicks off its seasonal return. Held on at City Hall, it’s the perfect place to browse local produce, fresh baked goods, tropical plants, handmade soaps, and island-inspired gifts. Grab a coffee, enjoy a walk through the shaded grounds, and chat with local vendors—this is a local favorite for good reason.

3. November 1 – F.I.S.H. 10K & 5K 🏃

Sanibel kicks off November with one of its most cherished community events: the FISH 10K/5K Race. This family-friendly race supports FISH of SanCap, a local nonprofit that provides essential services to residents and island workers. Whether you’re running, walking, or cheering from the sidelines, the energy is upbeat and community-focused. The flat, scenic course winds through the island’s quiet streets, making it perfect for seasoned runners and first-timers alike.

4. Halloween on the Island 🎃

If you're on the island for Halloween, don’t miss trick-or-treating in the Gumbo Limbo neighborhood. Locals know this is the spot for family-friendly fun, decorated homes, and generous candy hauls. It’s a safe, walkable area that turns into a festive gathering place on Halloween night—perfect for vacationing families looking to celebrate like a local.

5. Pre-Holiday Shopping on Periwinkle Way 🛍️

November is a great time to get a head start on holiday shopping. Browse the charming boutiques and galleries along Periwinkle Way for one-of-a-kind coastal gifts, handmade jewelry, artwork, and island-inspired home goods. Bonus: you’ll beat the winter crowds and support small local businesses.

6. Island Eats & Sunset Sips 🍰

Fall is the perfect season to enjoy outdoor dining without the summer heat. Grab a table on the patio at places like Gramma Dot’s, MudBugs, or Doc Ford’s, and enjoy a Gulf breeze with your seafood dinner. Want to cool off? Grab a frozen custard at The Shack — it hits the spot after a beach day or nature walk.

7. Sanibel Luminary Festival

As the holiday season begins, Sanibel Luminary Night is a magical event that kicks off December with glowing charm. On Friday, December 5, the island lights up with luminaria-lined paths, holiday music, decorated storefronts, treats, and cheerful island spirit. Local shop parking lots transform into a pedestrian-friendly festival where you can enjoy hot cider, meet Santa, and shop local for the holidays. Our favorite spot is the Sanibel Community Church which has food, elaborate Christmas lights, carolers, and activities for kids.

🍂 Plan Your Fall Getaway Now

Whether you’re chasing seashells, watching sunsets, or sipping coffee under the palms, Sanibel Island in the fall is full of small, beautiful moments. Our vacation rentals offer the perfect home base for your autumn escape—clean, comfortable, and cared for by locals who love the island as much as you will. Check our our island vacation rentals here!